Democratic statehood in international law by jure vidmar. The sahrawi arab democratic republic sadr was proclaimed by the polisario front on 27 february 1976, in bir lehlu, western sahara. This thesis rejects such arguments and takes the position that attributes of statehood are not dependent on type of government. Counter to the traditional literature on international. Democracy activists in the region therefore should not hesitate to invoke these essential elements. Democratic statehood in international law ebook by dr jure. The statehood criteria in contemporary international law are largely irrelevant and do not automatically or selfevidently determine whether or not an entity has emerged as a new state. Mar 28, 20 the statehood criteria in contemporary international law are largely irrelevant and do not automatically or selfevidently determine whether or not an entity has emerged as a new state.
It calls the territories under its control the liberated territories. The term democracy comes from the greek words demos, the people, and craits, to rule. Jure vidmar contact author maastricht university faculty of law email p. International recognition of the sahrawi arab democratic. The geology of international law governance, democracy and legitimacy j. Military and paramilitary activities in and against nicaragua nicaragua v u. Jure vidmars recent book democratic statehood in international law is an important contribution to these debates on what makes a state a state. The topic of statehood under international law has long been a favorite with jurists. Northern cyprus fulfills all the classical criteria of. The legitimacy of international law is provided by the requirement of. The process requires some democratic procedures to be followed. Starting from the concept of constitution familiar from the democratic nation state, some contributors even doubt that the concept can be meaningfully applied to refer to international law norms. International law and politics, history of diplomacy.
The statehood of collapsed states in public international law dialnet. In the past decade, however, the tendency has accelerated. International law operates within the political milieu but international law is to some extent distinct from that political system. The emergence of a new state is not an automatic or factual occurrence upon meeting the statehood criteria. The right of a people to selfdetermination is a cardinal principle in modern international law. Democratic legitimacy of international human rights law, the. Nauru is a tiny country in micronesia with a population of around 11,315 people according to the united nations yet is considered to be a state. Origin, meaning and scope of international human rights law 2. Palestinian statehood and the international law of democracy. Democratic rule of international law european journal of. In the classic view, international law and democracy are simply not related, as international law is to remain neutral visavis any political model.
Several scholars in this group have introduced arguments in favour of pil approaches to election observation. The normative case against authoritarian international law, then, rests partly on the idea that pro democratic international law was a feasible project, and also on the idea that general international law has benefitted the citizens of the democracies who have played a disproportionate role in its formation since world war ii. A group seeking selfdetermination is one which feels that it has been unjustifiably excluded from the community of states recognised by international law. What is meant by state recognition in international law. The classification of states and the creation of status. International law and democracy much of classical international law has been premised on, inter alia, the proposition that states and their governments are in the business of governance. In the book democratic statehood in international law, i develop an argument that state creation is a political process of overcoming a. In the most common understanding, democracy generally refers to a political system with certain. The stigmatization of states as a conceptof leadership a. The emergence of new states in postcold war practice, hart, 20, available at ssrn. United nations sres2334 2016 security council distr general 23 december 2016 resolution 2334 2016 adopted by the security council at its 7853 rd meeting, on 23 december 2016. State boundaries are endpoints up until the sovereignty of a state.
Chapter 1 international human rights law and the role of the. Under traditional international law it has been commonly assumed that four criteria must be met before an entity can be said to be a state. Grzybowski and others published international law and statehood. Necessarily, this latter development derives from institutions and processes that answer to a constituency beyond the democracy of the nation state. In the book democratic statehood in international law, i develop an argument that state creation is a political process of overcoming a competing claim to territorial integrity. In the words of the montevideo convention on the rights and duties of states, the state as a person of international law.
German democratic republic into the federal republic of germany in 1990. Ethiopia human rights report 28 june18 laramie, wyoming. The emerging right to democratic governance thomas m. One of the central points that runs through jures book is that states do not emerge automatically from the application of legal criteria the montevideo criteria or additional criteria pp.
Aneta stojanovskastefanova, phd candidate, teaching assistant, faculty of tourism and business logistics, university goce delcev, stip, republic of macedonia. Scholars in the field seek to identify the international and domestic factors that increase state commitment to international environmental treaties and agreements. Here, we are very much on the threshold of normative progress, and the question of palestine presents certain unique dimensions. Dec 07, 2012 jure vidmar, democratic statehood in international law. The limits of democratic decision making in territorial matters. I as a result of ideological tensions during the cold war, the international legal engagement with such a concept re. The emergence of new states in postcold war practice russell buchan. Lecturer and senior fellow, international law, bynkershoek institute, the. The concept of sovereignty is complex, it can be analyzed in terms of the national law, but as a member of international society, a state participates in international relations on the basis of. A democratic rule of international law 539 the arguments of risse and johnstone present important insights for accepting the democratic legitimacy of international law focused on the ability of states to develop international law norms through a process of communicative reason that approxi mates to the deliberative ideal. The right to political participation in international law.
Traditionally, only statehood could confer international legal personality, and its accompanying rights and duties, upon any group. Many constitutions specify the status of international law in domestic law. The respondent is the democratic republic of timorleste timorleste or the respondent. International constitutional law international law. Democratic legitimacy for law in the modern age depends on the following ideal conditions. Mar 31, 20 one of the current research endeavors in international environmental politics is understanding the link between democracy and international environmental protection.
The international response to the classification of rogue states iv. The polisario is an independence movement and political organization of sahrawis who have advocated for the independence of western sahara. The geology of international law governance, democracy and. The legal issues involved in the western sahara dispute. Democratic statehood in international law by jure vidmar ssrn. Based on the classical concept of sovereignty, states. International law is often enacted through the influence of nondemocratic governments and unaccountable, unrepresentative elites from democratic states.
Developments in actual state practice, including within and among member states of the council of europe, have shown that the criteria for statehood remain a contentious issue in international law. This paper is a based on the study strengthening international law to support democratic governance and genuine elections. It was prepared by the office of democracy and governance, rule of law division. This comprehensive study discusses state obligations under international law relevant to democratic governance and genuine. First, codification of political rights in international and regional human rights treaties accompanied democratization at the national level. The respondent has been an icsid contracting state since 22 august 2002. Some definitions of international law can be found on the web as follows. The problem of what constitutes a state has been extensively examined and discussed, but all too often in absolutist terms confined to drawing up lists of criteria which must be met before an entity may be deemed a state. The legitimacy of those standards is usually in reciprocal tension in a domestic. Finally, a third group of writings include work on public international law pil, particularly international human rights law, and its connection to democratic elections. International law states in international law britannica. Here responsibility may denote a competence, as is. The question to be asked, therefore, is not whether democracy has become a statehood criterion.
Jure vidmar, democratic statehood in international law. The body of laws governing relations between nations, international law is the term commonly used for referring to the system of implicit and explicit agreements that bind together nation states in adherence to recognized values and standards, differing from other legal systems in that it concerns nations. It is a member of the community for democracy and rights of nations along with. They have been accepted in numerous internationally agreed documents, some of which represent international law. The recent wave of democratization, however, has had ramifications for the conduct of international organizations, and consequently for international law. The annexation of crimea and the boundaries of the will of the. Democracy and state environmental commitment to international. Sadr claims sovereignty over the entire territory of western sahara, a former spanish colony.
International law rules and the rule of international law implies authority over its. Within the state, it is now accepted that the legitimacy of law depends on the institutionalization of democratic procedures. James crawford, democracy and international law, 64 british y. A central issue is whether the democratic representation of states involves any questions of international law. Sovereign states are the primary subjects of binding international law. Today, democracy is an abstract term that is difficult to define and can have different meanings, depending on the speaker and context. Law creation through leadership and the role of reaction 3. Introduction international law has traditionally been neutral towards the concept of an entitlement to democracy. Uvadare digital academic repository research explorer.
States are aggregates of the individuals and as such a permanent population is a criterion for statehood. The topic of statehood under international law has long been a favorite with. In particular, the drg assessment recommends that the united states agency for international. International law s authority is justified or legitimate, however, only if it has the right to rule, i. The democratic process in this context governs independence referenda and does not interfere with the choice of a political system. Vidmar, jure, democratic statehood in international law. The transformation of the democratic entitlement from moral prescription to international legal obligation has evolved gradually. Jure vidmar is professor of public international law, maastricht university, the netherlands. This does not mean that international law rejects democracy.
The rule of law strategic framework a guide for usaid democracy and governance officers august 2008 this publication was produced by the united states agency for international development. Even the assent of democratic nations to international human rights norms is often cheap talk. Traditionally, international law has barely paid attention to the democratic legitimacy of its most important subjects states, having been concerned only with relations between states and. Introduction traditionally, international law has barely paid attention to the democratic legitimacy of its most important subjects states, having been concerned only with relations between states and not within them. United yemen took over the recognition made by south yemen. At the same time however, it seems that a state cannot exercise its full legal rights under international law without recognition by other states. This book analyses the emerging practice in the postcold war era of the creation of a democratic political. The right to selfdetermination and international law. The democracy, governance, and human rights drg assessment recommends that development agencies follow suit to take advantage of these opportunities quickly to deepen democratic development in guyana. In region after region, political change has swept through the former bastions of authoritarian and dictatorial rule, offering the promise, if not always the reality, of. National sovereignty and statehood in contemporary. Acces pdf associated statehood in international law.
The geology of international law governance, democracy. Concept of statehood in united nations practice penn law. Considering the significance of the term sovereignty, the importance and role of the decision whether a country will be internationally recognized or not is becoming clear, as well as the necessity of each territory and. As far as existing states are concerned, democracy is not an ongoing requirement for statehood. As international law and international relations are becoming increasingly significant for all states, however, constitutions are beginning to deal with these issues as well. Once the exercise of domestic political selfdetermination is understood in the context of the authority of international law, the choice is straightforward. The rules of international law favor the stability of the existing international borders and thus. The admission of new states to the international community. Individuals may, for example, assert their rights under international law under the. Introduction 1 the principle of sovereignty, ie of supreme authority within a territory, is a pivotal principle of modern international law. Arrest warrant case of 11 april 2000 democratic republic of the congo v. International human rights law allows outsiders to participate in decisions that on this view should be left only to us, members of the nation state.
What counts as sovereignty depends on the nature and structure of the international legal order and viceversa. The end of the cold war also coincided with the dissolutions of two. Emergency measures and the rule of law in the age of covid. Introduction in the past two decades, or so, there have been claims by many distinguished international law and political science scholars that a norm of, or right to, democratic. International law perspectives corte interamericana. Using international law to assess elections website. One of the challenges before every legal system in the current age is how. The article examines the process of democratic transition in the non state entity of. Odious debts and state succession the neutral position of classic international law on democracy is illustrated by the. Most remarkable is the extent to which an interna tional law based entitlement is now urged by governments themselves.
714 450 378 679 803 1657 1163 832 1504 662 206 460 1531 1573 1066 211 290 892 208 459 664 259 1646 591 925 1079